Adults Who Chase Their Past: Makoto Shinkai and Ghibli

This is pretty much the most obvious connection but the whole movie is littered with similar references.

I’ll admit that I’m hesitant to write a post about Shinkai’s Children Who Chase Lost Voices after Doc’s fantastic post, but the movie was fantastic and has compelled me to tackle a different part of the film than the ideas of the movie and instead the oft-mentioned influence from Ghibli, especially from Laputa.

It would be difficult not to see the numerous connections that are littered throughout the movie. Supposedly Shinkai has said that Laputa was his favorite movie as a child, and it shows from the blue stones, the collapsing civilization long lost from history, or the way the Quetzalcoatl is very similar to the robot in Laputa. The comparisons don’t end at Laputa though, with Shin’s very Ashitaka-like exile and Mimi’s resemblance to Teto from Nausicaa, Shinkai obviously had a certain prominent studio in mind while making this film.


What interests me more, though, are the differences between Children Who Chase Lost Voices and the Ghibli films that inspired it, especially Laputa. One thing that immediately struck me was the fact that Agartha is located under the earth, as opposed to Laputa‘s castle in the sky. I think this immediately clued me in that Shinkai had a very different plan for his world than the Adventure! present in Laputa, as this journey to a different location led us to a darker place  than the wondrous dream of living in the air.

Similarly, the magic presented in Children is far more terrifying than anything present in Miyazaki’s movies, perhaps barring Princess Mononoke (which I haven’t seen since middle school, perhaps something I should soon remedy). While the “magic” in Laputa is ultimately a danger, it’s only a danger because of the misuse by the humans who created it. Similarly, in Princess Mononoke and Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, the destruction wrought by the supernatural forces is only a result of the abuse committed by humans. In Shinkai’s film, however, magic seems to bring only ruin if it is trifled with, from the Izoku’s attempt to devour any Toplanders who wander into Agartha, to the frailty of Agartha’s residents when they enter our own world, and especially what happens when Morisaki reaches Gate of Life and Death.

These differences, along with the themes the film tackles that Ghibli would hesitate to touch on, seem to signify an attempt to break new ground with anime. For all the similarities to Ghibli, I was actually heavily reminded of Xam’d throughout the movie. Not that Children Who Chase Lost Voices was inspired by Xam’d,  but instead that they seem to be new attempts to use the advantages of animation to convey a very foreign fantasy world. While Western fantasy seems content stick to its medieval setting (something I’m not complaining about, mind you), these two works represent new ways of really pushing the potential of the fantasy genre. I’d actually argue that fantasy is a setting rather than a genre except in the case of works like these, where the fantasy is truly intrinsic to the themes and ideas of the story.

The clothing especially helps Agartha stand out as a very different place from where Asuna and Morisaki have come from.

It’s a very exciting direction for Shinkai to head, and I hope that more works follow in its footsteps. Perhaps we’ll see a time when films are referencing him but instead of repeating his accomplishments head in a unique direction.

Adults Who Chase Their Past: Makoto Shinkai and Ghibli

7 thoughts on “Adults Who Chase Their Past: Makoto Shinkai and Ghibli

  1. Another thing that reminded me of Studio Ghibli was that I came away from this film feeling a bit hopeful, which sets it in stark contrast to Shinkai’s other works, which just make me feel lonely.

    1. Bonen no Max'd says:

      This struck me less as Shinkai being influenced by Ghibli and more of him trying to break away from his pattern he’d established, though most people that I talk to would call 5 cm/s a hopeful ending anyways.

  2. When I first watched the film, I felt that the Miyazaki love was so strong, that I had difficulty sometimes viewing the film as something different than a twisted Ghibli film.

    That’s also an interesting connection you make to Xam’d. I started watching that series last year, and plan to return to it in the near future – I’ll be on the lookout for connections between it and this movie when I pick it up again.

    1. interesting: Do you mean “twisted” as in he is attempting to say/do what Miyazaki does but it turns out differently because of his worldview, or do you mean “twisted” as in, he takes things in a different direction because he thinks he has got it right and Miyazaki has got it wrong about certain things?

      1. The earlier (though I can’t deny it could be the latter). It seemed to me like a love letter to Miyazaki’s films, but like you say, featuring Shinkai’s themes and ideas. There’s so much to gather from the film – so much more depth than I originally expected to find.

        1. It’s almost like a man who has been uttering the same simple sentence over and over suddenly makes this eloquent series of statements. This is all the more jarring because of what has come (repeatedly) before.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s